Thursday, January 31, 2008

why are we supporting israel?

MIDEAST: Faeces Change the Face of Gaza
By Mohammed Omer

GAZA CITY, Jan 28 (IPS) - A stream of dark and putrid sludge snakes through Gaza's streets. It is a noxious mix of human and animal waste. The stench is overwhelming. The occasional passer-by vomits.

Over recent days this has been a more common sight than the sale of food on the streets of Gaza, choked by a relentless Israeli siege. Hundreds of thousands of Gazans, almost all of its able male adults among a population of 1.5 million, crossed over into Egypt last week to buy essential provisions - and a new lease of life. That has staved off starvation. But streets continue as sewers.

The rain has not helped. The sludge has spread, and the stench with it. Starved of timely income and essential supplies, municipal services have all but ceased.
"The smell," says Ayoub al-Saifi, 56, grimacing as he holds a handkerchief over his nose and mouth. "The stench of the sewage...my wife has asthma, and she can't breathe."

Saifi lives next to what has become a newly formed pool of waste. This used to be the street leading to home. "It's getting worse day by day," says neighbour Said Ammar, an engineer, and father of four.

The sewage treatment plant in al-Zaytoun neighbourhood in Gaza City requires 20,000 litres of fuel a day. Last week Israel ceased delivery of all fuel and supplies to Gaza. The consequences have been catastrophic.

Without fuel to pump it away, the waste backs up, flooding the streets and clogging the plumbing. The local ministry of health has declared this an environmental catastrophe.

Doctors have warned that a medical catastrophe could follow by way of spread of cholera and other diseases. That is at a time when not even life-saving medical services are on offer any more.

"We have to choose between cutting the electricity on babies in the maternity ward, cutting it to heart patients, or shutting down our operating rooms," says Dr. Mawia Hasaneen, director of emergency at al-Shifa Hospital, the largest in Gaza.

The World Health Organisation released a statement Jan. 22 warning of serious health difficulties arising in Gaza Strip, isolated by the Israeli siege, the Egyptian border and the Mediterranean Sea.

"Frequent electricity cuts and the limited power available to run hospital generators are of particular concern, as they disrupt the functioning of intensive care units, operating theatres, and emergency rooms," the WHO said. "In the central pharmacy, power shortages have interrupted refrigeration of perishable medical supplies, including vaccine."

Christine McNab, acting director in the communications department in Geneva adds that "our current concerns are about the supply of electricity to health facilities, the ability to move medical supplies into the region, and the ability of people to seek care outside of Gaza.

"McNab notes that even if the full blockade is lifted, additional measures would need to be taken by the international community against any further disruptions.

Israel has blocked off fuel and supplies to Gaza because it says it faces rocket attacks from the Palestinian area, which elected Hamas, the Palestinian party that does not recognise Israel.

Official Israeli sources say that about 150 homemade rockets have been fired from Gaza into Israel since Israel commenced this latest raid. Two Israelis have been slightly wounded and several others treated for shock.

Israel has retaliated with firing from tanks and attacks by F-16 aircraft firing Hellfire missiles into Gaza's neighbourhoods. At least 76 Palestinians have been killed, and another 293 injured since Jan. 1, officials here say.

Through the suffering, many Palestinians still do not blame Hamas.

"Hamas has never been the problem. The occupation has always been the big problem," says Ammar. He instead blames Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, who administers the West Bank Palestinian area, and who has been in talks with Israel.

"Abbas doesn't deserve one percent of the respect that (former Palestinian leader Ysser) Arafat earned. Israel will never find someone as good as Arafat. He gave them a historical chance at two states. Yet despite this, they (Israel) laid siege to him."

Rajaa Shalil, 38, and mother of four in Rafah at the Egyptian border, says "my respect for Hamas has increased more than ever. I love them for their empathy for the weak."

But not all of Gaza's residents feel this way. "Both Israel and Hamas are the reason for this," says resident Abu Mohammed. "Before, we were all in better conditions, but since Hamas took over Gaza they have been unable to handle it." (END/2008)

3 Comments:

At 11:41 AM, Blogger Cayusa said...

While I don't stand behind everything Israel has done, it is real easy to isolate one situation and paint Israel as the bad guy.

Israel is in a no win situation though. If they sit back and do nothing, rocket attacks will increase against them and suicide bombers will target more and more locations within Israel. This has happened time and time again. The Palestinian governments don't recognize Israel as a country and will continue to attack them until they are NO MORE or until the general population stands up and says enough is enough to the terrorists.

When Israel attacks them back in response to rocket attacks or suicide bombings innocent civilians are killed or injured. What you have to remember is that Israel isn't just firing rockets and missiles into crowded market places. They are attacking locations from which rocket launches against Israel have taken place or locations where terrorists are believed to residing. Israel makes every attempt NOT to kill civilians. The problem is, just as we saw during the skirmish with Lebanon, the terrorists attack from civilian locations. They launch rockets from occupied apartment buildings.

Israel has cut electricity and fuel to Gaza and civilians are suffering, probably most of whom just want to live their regular life. Yet they support a government who refuses to acknowledge Israel's right to exist and a government that sponsors terrorism. They can't have it both ways. You can't ask for peace and then launch rockets at another people.

You ask why we support Israel. We support them because they are the only democracy in the middle east. We support them because they aren't terrorists. We support them because we were instrumental in the creation of the country.

It is a hard call to make, but the alternative it much worse. If the rocket attacks and terrorism against Israel would stop then Israel wouldn't have to take the measures that they have and the retaliation would stop.

If Israel were to stop the retaliation and restore full electricity and fuel do you honestly believe that the rocket attacks against then would cease?

 
At 5:20 PM, Blogger tali said...

hey stranger :)

let me clarify - i'm not painting them as THE badguy, but as A badguy.

these aren't accidental casualties of a retaliatory bombing. these are women and children in hospital beds being deprived of medical care by what the rest of the world calls their rightful government.

this is more like DC cutting off the power to New Jersey to flush out a mob boss.

you've voiced in the past a disdain for the way native americans were treated by the us government. do you not see the parallels here?

that said - good to hear from you :)

 
At 1:42 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

As far as I understand it, the US hasn't exactly been showering Israel with praise over how it is handling the current situation in Gaza, but Israel is really stuck between a rock and a hard place when it comes to that situation.

If Israel cuts the flow of power and fuel then the terrorists suffering. It has the unfortunate side effect of hurting innocent people as well. If they don't cut the flow then the innocent people don't suffer, but then neither do the terrorists.

I'm not defending Israel's actions here, but then I'm not 100% condemning them either. I don't believe the Palestinians to be naive enough to think that their electing a terrorist government would benefit them. I think they did it out of frustration that things weren't getting taken care of as quickly as they liked. They had to know, however, that Israel wouldn't deal with a government whose major platform is that Israel must cease to exist.

You ask why we support them. The answer is that they are our strongest ally in that part of the world. We may not like every choice they make, but if we don't support them, things would be worse. We support them because they are the lesser of two evils.

I know Israel would prefer to live in peace, but as long as the Palestinians throw their support behind terrorists there won't be peace. I don't know that there will ever be full peace there, but the two have coexisted relatively peacefully (comparitively) in the past.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home